When they buy
"organic" foods,
consumers can now be a
little more confident they
are getting something
produced and processed
without chemical
fertilizers, pesticides or
preservatives. Starting
tomorrow, fruit,
vegetables, meat, milk and
other products labeled
organic can carry a
Department of Agriculture
seal.
The seal will
testify that the U.S.D.A.
has examined the practices
of farmers, processors and
packagers to ensure
standards Congress set in
1990. Meats and dairy
products can be labeled
organic only if the
animals were not given
growth hormones, for
example, or antibiotics.
Chips, frozen dinners or
other foods with organic
products can be certified
as organic if 95 to 100
percent of the ingredients
meet the standards. If at
least 70 percent are
organic, the food can be
labeled "made with
organic ingredients";
if less than 70 percent,
the food cannot have
distinct labels, but
organic contents can be
listed on the nutrition
panel.
Michael F.
Jacobson, executive
director of the Center for
Science in the Public
Interest, a nonprofit
health advocacy group in
Washington discussed the
new labeling in a recent
interview.
Q. Why did you support
federal oversight of
organic food labels?
A. There were lots of
suspicions that people out
there were charging twice
as much for conventionally
grown food simply by
putting it under a sign
that said organic. That
could have been hurting
consumers if there was
some deception in the
market. It was also
hurting the organic
industry, because people
simply hadn't had the
confidence that food they
were buying was really
organic. The way of
conveying to a consumer
that a food is grown
organically is to put a
label on the food. The
label needs to mean
something, and the law
will ensure that it does.
Q. Might some farmers opt
out of certification and
forgo an organic seal,
since the process is
voluntary?
A. I'd be surprised that
farmers who go to the
expense of growing foods
organically and want to
market them as organic
wouldn't get
certification. It's like a
ticket to print money,
because you can get a
significant premium. The
same thing for retailers.
They charge more money for
organic food, so you want
to use organic whenever
you can.
Q. Will companies pass on
to consumers the cost of
redesigning packaging to
showcase the seal?
A. That's a trivial part
of the cost of the final
price of the food.
Q. Will seals make people
think organic is healthier
than non-organic?
A. I suspect a lot of
people think organically
grown food is more
nutritious than
conventionally grown food.
I haven't seen evidence of
that. People also think
organically grown food is
safer. It might be a bit
safer, but the general
food supply is basically
safe. Organically grown
food could be contaminated
with dangerous bacteria.
It could be high in
saturated fat. Hopefully,
people won't think that
just because it's organic,
it's automatically
perfectly fine.
Q. Who will benefit most
from the new labels?
A. Organic farmers and
retailers. The label is
going to increase consumer
confidence and really
build this market. Twelve
years ago, we really were
hoping that this
legislation would help
small farmers and food
co-ops. That world is
changing where now we have
billion-dollar supermarket
chains, huge multithousand-acre
organic farms. Because
organic agriculture is
more labor intensive,
that's an incentive to
import organic foods from
low-wage countries like
Mexico. It's going to be
interesting to see who are
the ultimate
beneficiaries. It may not
be the small local farmer
or the local food co-op.
It may be big farms in
Mexico.