To:
Thinkingallowed@bbc.co.uk |
|||
Dear Laurie et
al. at
Thinking
Allowed,
Yesterday evening I watched with jaw-dropping interest the BBC 1 documentary, "When Satan Came to Town", about the Manchester families whose children were taken into care in the early 1990's because social workers wrongly suspected the parents of "devil worship" and child abuse. I remember hearing about it at the time and, like most other people, assuming that there must, surely, be something to it. To learn that the suspicions were not just untrue, but also completely unfounded, in view of the traumatic experiences these families were subjected to as a consequence, is deeply disturbing - but, from a scientific (sociological, psychological, anthropological and historical) perspective, also extremely interesting and important (thus me addressing this to you at Thinking Allowed).
When first
learning about
the horrors
and
irrationalities
of medieval
history, I
remember my
deep sense of
thankfulness
for living in
modern, humane
and rational
times, but
occasionally
wondered how
come things
had changed so
much in just a
few short
centuries.
Slowly and
with
increasing
anxiety, I
came to
realise that
things haven't
changed nearly
as much as I'd
assumed.
There's a
biblical
saying about
removing the
plank of wood
from one's own
eye before
pointing out
the splinter
in someone
else's. The
truth is that
we ALL have a
plank of wood
in our eye,
which, because
it has always
been there
(and we ALL
have it), is
extremely
difficult (if
not
impossible) to
see.
Politicians
and academics,
of
course, must
also deny it,
even to
themselves,
for
professional
reasons.
Removing it
would reveal
what I refer
to as the "insanities
of normality
", which
permeate and
form a huge
and essential
part of our
world.
Essential, in
the sense that
without them,
or anything to
take their
place, we
would go mad
(and hungry).
I have slowly
become aware
of some of
them, and
thereby retain
my sanity -
although many
would probably
disagree . . .
Whenever we
become
aware of some
horror or
gross
irrationality
in the world
(mainly
through the
media), we
immediately
distance
ourselves from
it, unwilling
or unable even
to contemplate
the
possibility
that WE
ourselves
might be
capable of the
same or
anything
similar.
Instead, we
use the
contrast to
confirm, to
ourselves and
to others,
that, at least
relatively
speaking, we
are "good",
"responsible" and
"rational"
individuals.
The truth,
however, is
that we are
NOT. Most
importantly,
we are ALL
participating
in the
plundering
and spoiling
of our planet:
a horrendous
crime against
our own
children and coming
generations,
for which they
(those who
survive) will surely
curse us.
Laurie, if
social
scientists,
like yourself,
cannot see
what is going
on, what we
are doing and
where we are
heading, who
can?
|
|||
|